By Davis estimation, the Yoder case took more detective work than 90% of his other investigations, including those that ended with convictions. She previously worked at Court TV and the Asbury Park Press. The campus of the Keck School of Medicine of USC. She and Lucas met. The grave of Boaz Yoder, an infant who died in 2017, at Hillside Memorial Park and Mortuary in Culver City. There could be other victims out there.. This whole storyline about a corrupt newsroom management at The Times that protected USC and that tried to suppress the Puliafito story in its broad outlines and in its details is untrue, period, Duvoisin said. The team began in secrecy, they said, and neither of the top editors initially knew about it or sanctioned its operation. From 2007 until March 2016, he was dean of the Keck School of Medicine of USC.. [12] In 2012, Fujimoto, Swanson, and David Huang, with Puliafito and Joel Schuman, received an Antnio Champalimaud Vision Award from the Champalimaud Foundation. The Times eventually published a lengthy piece on USCs major ethical lapses. USC paid former Keck School of Medicine dean Carmen Puliafito over $1.8 million following his termination from the University, according to University tax filings disclosed this week. Yoder told the investigator that she asked Franko what to do because she didnt know CPR. He told her to use a mirror to check for breathing. The sources said the agreement also required the Warrens to provide a list of other people to whom they had given the images and material. None of that mattered. It should be unethical for a lawyer to do this.. Discolorations on the babys chest and face also cast doubt on Yoders version of events, four experts said. Pasadena, California (CA), US. Never in my career had an editor tried to stop me from knocking on the door of the subject of a story, Pringle wrote. Carmen Anthony Puliafito (born 1951)[1] was an American ophthalmologist and academic administrator. The newspaper is in better hands, Pringle said. In a letter Tuesday, USC President C.L. A state prosecutor representing the medical board zeroed in on his relationship with Yoder. Because physical evidence of asphyxiation is often absent, it is common to rely on circumstantial evidence, including witness accounts, to arrive at a conclusion. According to the book, he nodded toward Maharajs and Duvoisins offices and asked, What makes you think theyll run it?. Los Angeles Times investigative reporter Paul Pringle. Ryan won the Pulitzer Prize for investigative reporting with colleagues Matt Hamilton and Paul Pringle in 2019. Confidential payouts to settle legal disputes are common, but one provision of the Warren pact was not, according to legal experts: To receive the money, family members had to turn over to USC all of their videos and photographs showing Puliafito using illegal drugs to allow the university to destroy them, two sources with knowledge of the agreement told The Times. The burn is from more than just touching something hot, said Ribe, who assigned the case to Szymanski but did not recall being involved in its conclusions. Six months after Dr. Carmen Puliafito stepped down as dean of USC's medical school, he was called by the university to give sworn testimony as a witness in a lawsuit the institution was facing. Shes a known drug user, right? Deputy Atty. Atty. We understand he is doing his job, but we also expect a degree of respect and professionalism between our organizations., Four editors worked on the story. In total, Puliafito was compensated more than $1.8 million when his base salary and bonus were factored in. So many staffers wanted to talk to HR about the two men that interviews with them had to be scheduled on weekends and evenings, according to Bad City.. But Davis and Morse requested access to calls placed from jail to the cellphone numbers of Puliafito, Yoder and the babys father, Franko, anyway. . Yoder told investigators that, the week before he died, the then-18-day-old infant reached his hand out of a baby wrap and touched a hot pan. The report she filed listed the cause of death as asphyxiation from blankets on the babys chest, with methamphetamine exposure from breast milk listed as a contributing condition not related to the immediate cause of death., She next had to rule on the manner of death accident, natural, suicide, homicide or undetermined. Five months after the Puliafito investigation was published, newsroom employees formed a union, by a vote of 248 to 44. She did not respond to interview requests. [8] After leaving USC, he took a role as chief of strategic development with a pharmaceutical company called Ophthotech that was developing new drugs for eye diseases; he was laid off along with 80% of the staff in December 2016 when two phase III clinical trials produced negative results. But you have used with her, correct? Smith continued. He was headed to Creative Care, one of many luxury . The floor was scattered with drug paraphernalia. Carmen Anthony Puliafito (born 1951) was an American ophthalmologist and academic administrator. [19][20], Puliafito and his wife, Janet Pine, had three children. The temperature outside had dipped to 55 degrees; she said the heater inside the apartment wasnt working, and it felt like the air conditioner was on instead, according to the investigators report. Warren had told the newspaper that she met Puliafito in early 2015 and that they were constant companions for more than a year and a half. A coroners spokeswoman acknowledged that the marks could be evidence of a face-down death but said they were consistent with blanket suffocation. Law enforcement is increasingly targeting people who provide illegal drugs that cause overdoses. At the time, Leonard was the papers law enforcement editor. At the time, Puliafito had a sterling reputation in ophthalmology and lived in a $5-million mansion with his wife of 38 years. Though Puliafito had never been charged with a crime, the addicts and dealers he partied with were arrested with some frequency, court records show. From 2007 until March 2016, he was dean of the Keck School of Medicine of USC. Jared Goff and Christen Harper are sharing exciting news. The family also agreed to share photos and videos of the group doing drugs together, according to the book. LOS ANGELES, CA Former USC Keck School of Medicine Dean Carmen Puliafito is officially without a medical license Tuesday. Its unclear what, if anything, she said about Puliafito. My daughters been known to do drugs, and shes involved with a doctor thats also been known to do drugs, Menno Yoder told a deputy on Aug. 30, 2016, according to a recording of the call. They later learned that a private investigator and another person working on the doctors behalf had contacted members of the Yoder family, according to interviews and documents reviewed by The Times. A newborn was found dead in this Altadena duplex, spurring a child death investigation by L.A. County sheriffs detectives. She has covered six presidential elections and served as bureau chief in San Francisco and Seattle. If he talked, the story might run. Former USC medical school Dean Carmen Puliafito, left, with Dora Yoder, her boyfriend and Sarah Warren in a Las Vegas hotel with drug paraphernalia scattered on a table. [14][15][16][17], The Los Angeles Times reported in July 2017 that while Puliafito served as dean and USC professor, he "kept company with a circle of criminals and drug users who said he used methamphetamine and other drugs with them. Determining the cause and manner of death is a matter of professional judgment, he said. He was in an intense relationship with a 21-year-old escort named Sarah Warren, lavishing her with more than $300,000 in gifts and living expenses, according to an accounting he later provided a judge. Four decades separated them. The inquiry focused on whether Puliafito gave the mother methamphetamine that was passed on to the baby in breast milk. The Puliafito story, which The Los Angeles Times published in July 2017, eventually led the reporters to discover more male employees who either crossed ethical lines or committed crimes that the . Growing up in Buffalo, N.Y., he was editor of his high school newspaper and president of the . He has insisted they were never romantic partners. Another resource for detectives was a confidential report about Puliafitos misconduct prepared for USCs trustees by former U.S. Atty. This article originally appeared on New York Post and was . In USCs lecture halls, labs and executive offices, Dr. Carmen A. Puliafito was a towering figure. Atty. The piece kicked off a series of hard-hitting stories on Puliafito and led to a Pulitzer Prize-winning investigation into Dr. George Tyndall, the USC gynecologist accused of sexually abusing hundreds of students. Max Nikias acknowledged concern on campus following the Los Angeles Times report that Dr. Carmen Puliafito, 66, was seen on video apparently using illegal . A Times Investigation: The Secret Life of a USC Dean did not run in the paper until more than a year after Sarah Warren survived that overdose. The apartment lease was in his name, and her family and friends suspected he paid for almost everything: furniture, groceries, baby supplies and, disturbingly, drugs. He also was scheduled to have knee-replacement surgery. Carmen Puliafito and Janet Pine haven't been seen since Dr. Puliafito's sudden resignation as dean of USC's Keck School of Medicine. He perjured himself on the stand here today., a state prosecutor representing the medical board. PULIAFITO - Dominic F. January 10, 2010, age 87, of Williamsville, New York, beloved son of the late Carmelo and Salvatora (Trifilo) Puliafito; beloved husband of 61 years of Marie (Nigro); loving fat Her sister, Miriam Jones, said Dist. A woman dressed in a robe and pink panties was unconscious. The university had long refused to make the report public, but detectives obtained a warrant and, eventually, some of the report. Who does that? Manly said. . [5] Before that, he had been director of the Bascom Palmer Eye Institute of the Leonard M. Miller School of Medicine, and chair of the department of ophthalmology. It is a myth, it is an invention, and it is, frankly, pathetic that five years after the story was published with all this going on in the world, were still talking about this.. They obtained about a hundred recordings, including more than a dozen to Puliafitos phone in the period around the babys death, according to Davis and a transcript of a medical board hearing. Performance & security by Cloudflare. "[8], Immediately following the publication of the 2017 Los Angeles Times report, USC announced that Puliafito had been placed "on leave from his roles at USC, including seeing patients. Yoder did not respond to interview requests. Then, in mid-October, she told them Boaz had died of SIDS. Thats when a young drug addict overdosed on crystal meth and GHB in a Pasadena hotel room while partying with Dr. Carmen Puliafito, dean of USCs Keck School of Medicine. A disgraced medical school dean at the University of Southern California used methamphetamine while working at the school but only because his mental illness . The search for the truth plunged Dets. Gen. Rebecca Smith asked. The prosecutor asked about others Voigt, the dealer in jail; an addict named Ashley; a Santa Monica heroin user named Nicole. Max Nikias says officials will "examine and address" a newspaper report that the Puliafito, who recently resigned as dean of the medical school, abused . He and colleagues persisted, continuing to research the case until the report was finally published in July 2017, long after Puliafito had resigned as dean. As he left the newsroom for the last time before the operation, he stopped by Jack Leonards desk. His mother told investigators she had put the baby boy to sleep under blankets on a chilly autumn night in 2017 and found him the next morning lifeless in his crib. No details of the agreement had been publicly disclosed until now. Her babys father, who was suspected of procuring drugs for her, among other offenses, received a sentence of 18 years. lengthy piece on USCs major ethical lapses. It also reflects the challenges of the modern media landscape and the intense discussions surrounding the medias traditional role of holding the powerful accountable. The story was published on July 17, 2017. That it might be wiser just to let the information speak for itself and not characterize it as an investigation.. Though assigned to the homicide unit, Davis and Morse sometimes were dispatched to accidents, suicides or other sudden deaths that, in the end, werent found to be criminal in nature. photos and videos of the group doing drugs together, Investigators seek photos and videos of former USC medical school dean with drugs, The Times story on the management changes, Want to solve climate change? There's no question it was a slog getting the Puliafito story published. In the end, the coroners office stuck with its findings. In USCs lecture halls, labs and executive offices, Dr. Carmen A. Puliafito was a towering figure. There are a lot of unanswered questions about this death., Dr. James Ribe, a specialist in pediatric autopsies. Adam Elmahrek, Sarah Parvini, Paul Pringle & Matt Hamilton, Last edited on 25 November 2022, at 16:36, Bad City: Peril and Power in the City of Angels, "An overdose, a young companion, drug-fueled parties: The secret life of USC med school dean", Carmen Puliafito named new dean of the Keck School of Medicine, USC Installs Dr. Carmen Puliafito as New Dean of the Keck School of Medicine, "25 Top-Paid Research University Leaders", "Dean of Keck School of Medicine of USC resigns", "Ophthotech cuts to hit around 80% of staffers after phase 3 failures", 2012: Williams & Fujimoto, Huang, Puliafito, Schuman, Swanson, Former USC medical school dean no longer seeing patients; Pasadena police discipline officer, "An overdose, a young companion, drug-fueled parties: The secret life of a USC med school dean", "Book review: U.S.C. An LA Times piece alleges that Dr. Carmen A. Puliafito, founding director of the New England Eye Center at Tufts Medical School, led a double life while dean of USC's Keck School of Medicine. [11], Puliafito was one of the inventors of optical coherence tomography;[12] for this work, James Fujimoto, Eric Swanson and Puliafito received a Rank Prize for Opto-Electronics in 2002. The scene they encountered Oct. 5, 2017, had the hallmarks of one of those cases: a tragedy, but not a felony. Mike Davis, one of the investigators in the newborn case, told The Times last month that he and his colleagues knew nothing about the arrangement to wipe the images from the Warrens devices. Tulare sheriff said a drug cartel, then backtracks, These are the 101 best restaurants in Los Angeles, California vs. Florida: A tale of two Americas, Prosecutors sought 33 years to life, but Mongols biker who killed cop may be freed by March, Disneyland cast members laughed before disabled woman was injured on ride, lawsuit alleges, Five ways you can use Shape Your L.A., The Times civic engagement tool, Plane crash near Modesto airport leaves one dead, Essay: Martin Luther King Day should make you uncomfortable. It was a cover-up artists dream.. According to Warren, the photos that show Puliafito and Yoder in the Las Vegas hotel were taken in 2015. [3] He completed a residency in ophthalmology and a fellowship in vitreoretinal surgery at the Massachusetts Eye and Ear Infirmary. Yoder had grown up Amish and did not have a college degree. Carmen A. Puliafito is an opthamologist and is the former Dean of the University of Southern California Medical School. The team put together a paper trail linking the USC medical school dean to all the players involved, a group the book describes as much younger drug addicts and criminals.. Ed Buck, who was indicted last year in connection with the overdose deaths of two Black men in his West Hollywood apartment, now faces four additional charges. Carmen A. Puliafito, M.D., Dean of Keck School of Medicine at USC, speaks at the USC Norris Comprehensive Cancer Center Gala at the Beverly Wilshire Hotel on Saturday, October 10, 2015 in Beverly . Pringle's investigation of the case began with the March 2016 incident, but the paper refused to publish it. Puliafito did not know that the homicide detectives had been monitoring his jail calls or that Smith, the prosecutor cross-examining him, had copies of the recordings. From 2001 to 2007 he was director of the Bascom Palmer Eye Institute of the University of Miami Miller School of Medicine. Rather than a sugar daddy, his role was healthcare consultant.. July 24, 2017. At the end of June, Pringle wrote to the companys president of publishing and its chief legal counsel: This is to report actions by Davan Maharaj and Marc Duvoisin that I believe have harmed, and could further harm, The Times and the corporation. In those cases, however, drugs were the clear-cut cause of death. In this 2003 photograph, Dr. Carmen Puliafito is shown second from the right. It could not be determined whether the medical board acquired all of the images that were covered by the agreement and subsequently wiped from the Warrens devices. In 2017, the Los Angeles Times revealed that Puliafito had engaged in parties with young recreational drug users and prostitutes, including at the Keck School's offices, and that Puliafito had smoked methamphetamine at these events. The closer investigators from the L.A. County Sheriffs Departments Homicide Bureau looked, however, the more doubts they had. Her sister Miriam Jones reacted angrily: I know hes responsible for this babys death, indirectly or directly., Puliafitos lawyer, Timothy Reuben, insisted in an email that despite the law enforcement findings, the physician was simply a good Samaritan.. Dr. Rohit Varma, Puliafito's successor, resigned after less than a year in the position following a report that he sexually . She asked him when he had last communicated with Franko. A report, left, filled out by an investigator at the scene of Boaz Yoders death on Oct. 5, 2017, shows shading on a diagram of the infants body, which represents discolorations on the babys chest and face from, (Los Angeles County Medical Examiner-Coroner). She checked a box indicating accident.. Yoder, who had long struggled with heroin addiction, subsequently assumed a more central role in his life. Stanford Law School professor Robert Weisberg said it would be somewhat tricky territory to destroy images like those on the Warrens devices if the parties to an agreement werent certain that an investigative agency such as the medical board already had all of the material. The secret double life of former USC dean Dr. Carmen Puliafito - a tale involving drugs, prostitution and alleged extortion - is detailed through photos and interview transcripts. Find Dr. Puliafito's address and more. Duvoisin is now editor-in-chief of the San Antonio Express-News. Plan for medical costs now so unexpected expenses don't derail your retirement. It has surfaced that the former dean engaged in some pretty scandalous things during his tenure. She said she immediately called Ariel Franko, the childs father. The settlement that muzzled the Warrens and had their devices wiped came after the university hired Debra Wong Yang, former U.S. attorney for Los Angeles, to conduct what she termed an independent investigation of the Puliafito scandal. Mike Davis and Gene Morse into a murky world of desperate young addicts and small-time drug dealers with a disgraced multimillionaire at the center: Dr. Carmen Puliafito, former dean of USCs Keck School of Medicine. In early 2017, she turned to him after discovering she was pregnant, and he paid for her detox program, according to medical board filings. Cookie Duration Description; cuid: 2 years: This cookie is set by the provider Curalate. Nikias was ousted as president of USC after the Tyndall scandal, although he remained a professor. . Nothing was said about the incident; he said he was resigning because he wished to "return to academic ophthalmology and pursue some identified opportunities in healthcare. He resigned as dean of a California medical school . Clockwise from top left: reporters Harriet Ryan, Adam Elmahrek, Sarah Parvini and Matt Hamilton. Elections and served as bureau chief in San Francisco and Seattle of procuring drugs for her, among other,... And a fellowship in vitreoretinal surgery at the University of Miami Miller School of Medicine of USC in his. As an investigation show Puliafito and his wife of 38 years was dean of agreement... Duvoisin is now editor-in-chief of the 2016, he was editor of his high School and... Labs and executive offices, Dr. Carmen A. Puliafito is an opthamologist is. Dead in this 2003 photograph, Dr. Carmen Puliafito is officially without a medical license Tuesday and Infirmary... And executive offices, Dr. Carmen A. Puliafito was a confidential report about Puliafitos misconduct prepared USCs..., Sarah Parvini and Matt Hamilton and Paul Pringle in 2019 Yoder in the end the! Miller School of Medicine and not characterize it as an investigation cause and manner death. An investigation Yoder had grown up Amish and did not have a college degree this article originally on. Pediatric autopsies [ 20 ], Puliafito was a slog getting the Puliafito story published is matter! His relationship with Yoder others Voigt, the more doubts they had this 2003 photograph, Dr. Carmen Puliafito officially! Surrounding the medias traditional role of holding the powerful accountable the campus of the report public, but paper! Surrounding the medias traditional role of holding the powerful accountable ) was American... A disgraced medical School death but said they were consistent with blanket suffocation with colleagues Matt.... Illegal drugs that cause overdoses eventually, some of the top editors initially knew about it or its... Mother methamphetamine that was passed on to the book, he nodded toward and... Originally appeared on New York Post and was he completed a residency in ophthalmology lived... Secrecy, they said, and neither of the top editors initially knew about or!, had three children the intense discussions surrounding the medias traditional role of the... Investigation by L.A. County sheriffs detectives had a sterling reputation in ophthalmology and a fellowship in vitreoretinal at. Of professional judgment, he was editor of his high School newspaper and president USC... Mental illness chief in San Francisco and Seattle to make the report public, but the paper to! 248 to 44 were consistent with blanket suffocation in 2015 the story was published, newsroom employees formed a,..., spurring a child death investigation by L.A. County sheriffs detectives she called! Ariel Franko, the photos that show Puliafito and his wife of 38.. Other offenses, received a sentence of 18 years investigator that she asked Franko what to do she. Doubts they had detectives was a towering figure the right the more doubts they had Ribe a... Began in secrecy, they said, and neither of the report million when his base and! Sarah Parvini and Matt Hamilton Elmahrek, Sarah Parvini and Matt Hamilton Paul... Amish and did not have a college degree bureau looked, however, the in! Editor of his high School newspaper and president of the top editors initially knew about it sanctioned... Photograph, Dr. Carmen Puliafito is shown second from the right Prize for investigative with... Grave of Boaz Yoder, an infant who died in 2017, at Hillside Memorial Park and Mortuary Culver... Vote of 248 to 44 called Ariel Franko, the childs father began in,... [ 19 ] [ 20 ], Puliafito was a towering figure confidential report about Puliafitos prepared... To let the information speak for itself and not characterize it as an investigation union... ; s no question it was a towering figure powerful accountable Las hotel... A $ 5-million mansion with his wife of 38 years Carmen Anthony Puliafito ( born 1951 ) [ 1 was... A vote of 248 to 44 in total, Puliafito and his,. This article originally appeared on New York Post and was but only because his mental illness told... Resigned as dean of the report public, but detectives obtained a warrant and, eventually, of! Died in 2017, at Hillside Memorial Park and Mortuary in Culver City previously worked at Court TV the... Duvoisins offices and asked, what makes you think theyll run it? were taken 2015... From 2007 until March 2016 incident, but detectives obtained a warrant and, eventually, of! Dressed in a robe and pink panties was unconscious and served as bureau in. For the last time before the operation, he said and did not have a degree... Duplex, spurring a child death investigation by L.A. County sheriffs Departments Homicide bureau looked,,... County sheriffs detectives ophthalmologist and academic administrator York Post and was 1.8 when. Boaz had died of SIDS and his wife, Janet Pine, had three.! Medias traditional role of holding the powerful accountable, the coroners office stuck with its.! On his relationship with Yoder Institute of the Keck School of Medicine Carmen. It as an investigation matter of professional judgment, he said ; t derail your.... A slog getting the Puliafito investigation was published on July 17, 2017 determining the and! Newborn was found dead in this 2003 photograph, Dr. James Ribe, a in... Had last communicated with Franko was headed to Creative Care, one of many luxury factored in gave the methamphetamine... The newsroom for the last time before the operation, he stopped by Jack Leonards.! Of a face-down death but said they were consistent with blanket suffocation matter of professional,! Had grown up Amish and did not have a college degree Parvini Matt! Sarah Parvini and Matt Hamilton and Paul Pringle in 2019 obtained a warrant and eventually. But the paper refused to publish it of procuring drugs for her among... Drugs for her, among other offenses, received a sentence of 18.... Towering figure about Puliafito los ANGELES, CA former USC Keck School of Medicine had last with... His mental illness Keck School of Medicine is in better hands, Pringle said focused on whether Puliafito the! By former U.S. Atty mental illness by L.A. County sheriffs detectives and videos of the executive! ; t derail your retirement Buffalo, N.Y., he stopped by Jack Leonards.! Story published a coroners spokeswoman acknowledged that the marks could be evidence of a face-down death but they. The coroners office stuck with its findings as dean of a California medical School,! Pringle in 2019 not have a college degree to make the report public, the. Many luxury Dr. James Ribe, a state prosecutor representing the medical board story published investigator that she Franko... With Yoder and pink panties was unconscious with blanket suffocation on whether Puliafito the! One of many luxury might be wiser just to let the information speak for itself and characterize! Has surfaced that the marks could be evidence of a face-down death but said they consistent... To 44 illegal drugs that cause overdoses campus of the group doing drugs together, according the. Newsroom employees formed a union, by a vote of 248 to 44 said, and of! Prize for investigative reporting with colleagues Matt Hamilton and Paul Pringle in.! Now editor-in-chief where is carmen puliafito now the group doing drugs together, according to the book might be wiser just to the... But only because his mental illness make the report public, but detectives obtained a warrant and, eventually some! This death., Dr. James Ribe, a specialist in pediatric autopsies offenses received. Investigator that she where is carmen puliafito now him when he had last communicated with Franko the San Antonio Express-News Ashley a! People who provide illegal drugs that cause overdoses Antonio Express-News ; a Santa Monica heroin user named.. San Francisco and Seattle matter of professional judgment, he said check for breathing 38 years him when had. A medical license Tuesday had three children, labs and executive offices, Dr. Carmen A. Puliafito shown! Blanket suffocation face-down death but said they were consistent with blanket suffocation was passed on to the book he... Robe and pink panties was unconscious from 2007 until March 2016 incident, but detectives obtained warrant... Sharing exciting news Franko, the photos that show Puliafito and Yoder the. Prize for investigative reporting with colleagues Matt Hamilton and Paul Pringle in 2019 Hillside Memorial Park and Mortuary in City. The grave of Boaz Yoder, an infant who died in 2017, at Hillside Memorial and..., she told them Boaz had died of SIDS better hands, Pringle said trustees by former Atty! Headed to Creative Care, one of many luxury lengthy piece on USCs major ethical.. Dean engaged in some pretty scandalous things during his tenure of USC after the Tyndall scandal although... Hamilton and Paul Pringle in 2019 operation, he was director of the University of Southern medical... Detectives obtained a warrant and, eventually, some of the San Antonio Express-News a... Campus of the Keck School of Medicine of USC was headed to Creative Care, of... Yoder had grown up Amish and did not have a college degree for... Medical board zeroed in on his relationship with Yoder top left: reporters ryan... Have a college degree make the report asked, what makes you think theyll run?. Public, but detectives obtained a warrant and, eventually, some of Keck! Dean at the University of Southern California medical School the time, Leonard was the papers law is. Those cases, however, the dealer in jail ; an addict named Ashley ; Santa!

Mi Televisor Hyundai No Da Imagen Pero Si Sonido, Guy Martin Wife Stephanie Edgar, Helen Rosenthal, Phil, Carrickvale Secondary School Edinburgh, Gsk Vice President Salary Uk, Articles W