are autopsy reports public record in florida

See Jeffery v. McHugh, 166 W. Va. 379, 273 S.E.2d 837 (1980) (upholding the confidentiality of juvenile court records, which were specifically exempt from disclosure under West Virginia Code 49-7-1, even though the juvenile involved had died). STEP ONE: Find Death Information For deaths that exist during this time period, try the following database. 2. 19a-411. . AGO 073-51. Pursuant to RSA 611-A:8,III, autopsy reports are available only to the Department of Justice in situations involving homicide investigations. Records compiled in conjunction with autopsies performed by or at the direction of the Chief Medical Examiner are not considered public records pursuant to 1 V.S.A. . den., 520 So. In sum, autopsy reports made pursuant to law are public records which must be made available for public inspection and examination unless exempted by special act. Autopsy reports are subject to required public disclosure unless one of the Acts exceptions applies. + Florida State Records | StateRecords.org Florida Vital Records Business Login Contact (904) 204-7046 Instant Access to State, County and Municipal Public Records First Name: Last Name: City: Businesses, Click Here Chapter 2001-01, Laws of Florida, establishes that a "photograph or video or audio recording of an autopsy[1] in the custody of a medical examiner[2] is confidential and exempt" from public disclosure requirements in section 119.07(1), Florida Statutes, and Article I, section 24(a), Florida Constitution. 1251. Autopsy reports can help you find closure and give you insight into legal matters, especially if the persons death was unexpected. Code 36-2-14-10(e)(1)-(5). See Wait v. Florida Power and Light Company, 353 So.2d 1265 (1 D.C.A. Fla., 1977), which held that a widow seeking pension benefits from a city had no right under s. 119.01, F. S., to receive a copy of a homicide report concerning the death of her late husband. Consequently, if autopsy reports are medical reports in your state, the documents are not public records. You must show good cause Anyone may obtain a copy. Not public record. Theavailability of victim, as reports are autopsy record in public florida department of. As such, ensure to click on the death records options before proceeding - you can choose this option from a drop-down menu under vital records, as shown below. Public record if there is no pending criminal investigation. . Denver Publ'g Co. v. Dreyfus, 184 Colo. 288, 520 P.2d 104 (1974). Tex. The medical examiner's investigative report is privileged and confidential, and not subject to disclosure pursuant to AS 40.25. See, e.g., ss. Public record if there is no pending criminal investigation. 1976), requiring disclosure of a report concerning a death in a city detention facility. and the investigating law enforcement agency upon completion. La. But on the state level, whether an autopsy or a coroner's report is conducted and whether these evaluations are subject to public release vary widely. In the US, it depends on state law. Compare San Francisco Examiner v. Plummer, 19 Med. Kan. Atty Gen. Op. Verify the license status and disciplinary history of a healthcare professional or facility license in the State of Florida. Vital Records Explained: Are birth certificates public records? Mo.Rev.Stat. To obtain one, youll need to send in an autopsy request form to the coroners office, which can usually be found on your states medical examiner website. Check the website of the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner in your state for more information. Different states have varying privacy laws on who can obtain autopsy reports and results. 406.12, 406.13, and 406.14, F. S.? 406, F. S., of deaths under active investigation and felt to be caused by criminal conduct fall under the exception to Ch. Check authorization requirements The Details How long does a toxicology report take in Florida? Are autopsy reports public record Florida? Court (Hartfield), 134 Nev. 40, 4041, 412 P.3d 23, 24 (Nev. 2018) (vacating prior restraint order order that enjoined press from reporting on redacted autopsy report already in public domain). If not exempted from disclosure by special act, an autopsy report may be kept confidential only to the extent necessary to ensure that a criminal investigation would not be significantly impeded and enable violators of the criminal laws to escape detection and apprehension. This was reaffirmed by the Office of Open Records in holding that the Coroners Act requires broad disclosure of all applicable records such as autopsy, toxicology, inquisition, and coroner's reports. 2. However, this conclusion was framed in relation to the question posed which included autopsy reports and other records compiled by and in the possession of the state attorney which do not result in a criminal prosecution. [12] See Ch. The same law also amended Indiana Code Section 36-2-14-10 to declare autopsy photographs, video recordings, or audio recordings confidential for the purposes of 5-14-3-4(a)(1), except in certain instances involving a surviving spouse, a government agent acting in an official capacity, or a coroner using the materials for training or educational purposes. See 5 ILCS 140/7(1)(c); 5 ILCS 140/7(1)(a); see alsoTrent v. Coroner of Peoria County, 349 Ill. App. F.S.} See 51 W. Va. Op. The hospital is not allowed to give out any information about an autopsy or to respond to inquiries about an autopsy from any third parties. 25-19-105(b)(6), is applicable. Copies of autopsy reports are provided free to immediate next of kin (spouse, child,parent, sibling, grandparent, grandchildren). If wikiHow has helped you, please consider a small contribution to support us in helping more readers like you. There are no reported decisions on whether records relating to autopsies performed by coroners or medical examiners are subject to the Sunshine Law. 2006). Next of kin and family may request a copy. Autopsy photos, video and visual images, however, are not public records. 13.83, subd. Ind. [8] Audiotape of Senate floor debate on House Bill 1083, March 29, 2001; Audiotape of House floor debate on House Bill 1083, March 22, 2001. The public record of death but not. see, e.g., Matter of Rome Sentinel Co. v. Boustedt, 252 N.Y.S.2d 10 (N.Y. App. In Sum: --------------------------------------------------------------- Reports of autopsies performed at the request of the medical examiner or other designated public officials are open pursuant to the Public records law and pursuant to North Carolina G. S. 130a-389. . 1968). public record when investigations conclude. Atty Gen. Fla. 78-23 (1978) (autopsy reports made by a district medical examiner pursuant to Fla. Stat. SDCL 2-8-41. The Texas Public Information Act deems autopsies public information. 346-10 of welfare records); Disclosure of Autopsy Reports, OIP Op. Att'y Gen. 89-604. 2d 815, 817 (Fla. 1976); and see Ideal Farms Drainage Dist. It follows logically that a coroner's resulting autopsy reports constitute official records and papers' within the meaning of Section 1251.). But see Matter of Pennington v. Clark, 16 A.D.3d 1049, 791 N.Y.S.2d 774 (4thDept 2005) (Althoughautopsyphotographs are generallyexemptfrom disclosure underCounty Law 677 (3) (b), a court mayorder that the photographs be made available for inspection to a person having a substantial interest in a criminal action related to the contents of the record or investigation.), appeal denied, 5N.Y.3D 712, 840 N.E.2D 131 (2005). As further evidence that the Legislature did not intend all autopsy reports to be confidential, I would note s. 827.07(4)(b), F. S., Ch. C. 1210 et seq. The office of coroner has been abolished in more than one-third of North Carolinas counties. For instance, if you are in New York. unlocking this expert answer. 2d 327 (Fla. 1987). 406 (1991) are public records and should be held open to inspection by the public);Williams v. City of Minneola, 575 So. There are some exceptions, however, such as when the autopsy is part of an ongoing criminal . Please note that there is a fee for copies pursuant to Florida Statute 119. When the Social Security number is included, it can lead you to many other valuable vital records. The obvious purpose was an attempt by the Legislature to impose certain minimum uniform procedures by enactment of the Medical Examiners Act, Ch. . While in florida . state law, the provisions of this act shall not apply.). Ct., New York Cty., 1994) (denying access under FOIL to audiotape and autopsy worksheets pursuant to 557(g) of the New York City Charter). In 2001, a mandatory exception was added to bar disclosure of a photograph, a video recording, or an audio recording of an autopsy, except as provided in [Ind. Each state has its own rules with either the county or state government being in control of the autopsy report. Va. Code Ann. Division of Vital Records 6550 Reisterstown Rd. SeeN.J.A.C. 1979) (criminal proceeding is one instituted and conducted for the purpose either of preventing the commission of crime, or for fixing the guilt of a crime already committed and punishing the offender, as distinguished from a 'civil' proceeding, which is for the redress of a private injury); and Black's Law Dictionary, Administrative Hearing 42 (5th ed. In addition, deadly weapon and injury reports made under ORS 146.750 are confidential under ORS 146.780. 1. To access these records, interested parties are required to visit the record custodian and provide the necessary information to facilitate a record search and retrieval. Available to anyone demonstrating a tangible and direct interest., Open to family and next of kin. If it is found in an inquest into the death of a person that a crime has been committed on the deceased, and the report names the person who the jury believes committed the crime, the inquest is not to be made public until after the suspect has been arrested. Support wikiHow by . Florida Death Records are public records which are documents or pieces of information that are not considered confidential and can be viewed instantly online. OCME does not issue death certificates to the public. Copyright 2011 State of Florida, AG Recognizes Human Trafficking Prevention Month, Warning About Increase in Sextortion of Minors, New Evidence Before Floridas Immigration Trial, Guardian Stole $12,000+ from Disabled Adult. To make an online request for the Florida death record you need, go to the website of Vitalcheck and follow the instructions stated there. Autopsy reports are generally open to next of kin, family, insurance investigators, law enforcement and prosecutors. The State of Florida has very broad public records law, which require that, unless otherwise exempted by statute, any records made or received by any public agency in the course of its official business are available for inspection, unless specifically exempted by the Florida Legislature. Those seeking to have access to autopsy photographs and recordings for civil proceedings must obtain a court order unless they are a surviving family member entitled to obtain such record without a court order pursuant to section 1(2)(b) of the law. ." at 118, 958 N.E.2d 822). 2d 364, 390, 345 P.2d 47 (1959)("An autopsy report is a record that the coroner is required to keep (Gov. See Kilgore v. R. W. Page Corp., 259 Ga. 556, 385 S.E.2d 406 (1989) (Act applies to the office of coroner). 4. If you are a close family member to the deceased, you might be able to get your own copy of the autopsy report for your genealogy records. United States Social Security Death Index U.S., Social Security Death Index, 1935-2014 ($) U.S., Social Security Applications and Claims Index, 1936-2007, incomplete, ($). Next of kin can write a request for the detailed autopsy report, as well as other legitimate individuals such as treating physicians, law enforcement investigating the death, and county attorneys. The surviving spouse or, if no surviving spouse, the surviving parent(s), or if no surviving spouse or parent, an adult child may access the autopsy records, and a court may grant any person access to such materials upon a showing of good cause. Op. 91-33 (Dec. 31, 1991) (stating that privacy interest applies only to living individuals and allowing access); Toxicology Reports, OIP Op. Autopsy reports are subject to the balancing test. Death Records. D.C. Code Ann. Mo.Rev.Stat. Death records are available from 1877 to present. Read Attorney General Moody's Week In Review. See Fla. Stat. Anyone may request a copy if there is no pending investigation. But in closed criminal investigations a superior court may find that the public interest in disclosure outweighs any privacy interest asserted by the deceaseds next of kin and permit such photographs to be disclosed. . Section 406.13, F. S. When the cause of death has been established within a reasonable medical certainty by the district medical examiner or his associate, he shall so report or make available to the state attorney in writing his determination as to the cause of said death. Most records and reports of the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner regarding a specific medical examiner case are not public records. Compare s. 925.09, F. S., empowering the state attorney to have an autopsy performed, before or after interment, when he decides it is necessary in determining whether or not death was the result of a crime. 61-25; see also Public Access to Ambulance Report Form Concerning a Deceased Individual, OIP Op. Yourself, those involved in your claim, and of course the Florida . Any evidence or specimen coming into the possession of the medical examiner in connection with any investigation or autopsy may be retained by him or be delivered to one of the law enforcement officers assigned to the investigation of the death. In a telephone conversation, the medical examiner's office advised that the method used to shield the identity of the deceased in the photographs was to place a black strip over the eyes of the decedent and to keep confidential the names of the deceased. SDCL 34-26-9. Autopsy photographs and similar materials may also be withheld, in certain circumstances, under the personal privacy exemption, Ky. Rev. App. 406, F. S., constitutes an implied repeal of the confidentiality provisions of the special acts set forth above, I believe the better approach is to conclude that Ch. In Florida, exemptions apply to photographs, video and recordings from. 1979) (administrative hearing is an oral proceeding before an administrative agency consisting of argument or trial or both; [p]rocedural rules are more relaxed at such hearings as contrasted with civil or criminal trials). Record of Officers and Men of New Jersey in the Civil War, 1861-1865 This digital version of William S. Stryker's classic work is presented here by the New Jersey State Library. Under Maryland law, in most cases autopsy reports are public records. Death records are restricted for 50 years. confidential medical records you must have consent from next of kin/family, Public record. Open to. Table 2 below describes state statutes that directly address the disclosure of autopsy reports. However, inquest reports become presumptively public once a prosecutor files a certificate asserting that the case will not be presented to a grand jury, or files notice that a grand jury has returned an indictment or a no bill. Bos. Ct. April 2, 2001). An autopsy, necropsy, or post mortem examination refers to a surgical procedure aimed at establishing the cause of death. Department of Health 3 Capitol Hill Providence, RI 02908 Email us Directions . [9] Id. police reports are ordinarily confidential," only to the extent that the reports fall under the exception recognized in Lee, supra. Any person may obtain a copy. 1971); Denver Publishing Co. v. Dreyfus, 520 P.2d 104 (Colo. 1974); Evansville-Vanderburgh C.D.H. Public Records Requests; Programs; Topics; News; Information for . 2d 1018, 583 N.Y.S.2d 744 (Sup. Fla., 1962); and Caswell v. Manhattan Fire and Marine Ins. Code Ann. 2017), for determin[ing] if a government entity should redact information in a public records request. Clark Cty. O.C.G.A. Is the medical examiner permitted to show photographs of an autopsy for educational purposes at state medical schools, law enforcement agencies, state attorney offices, public defender offices, public hospitals, state or federal medical examiner's associations and any other public agencies? You may petition the court if you have good cause Open to: State law determines who has the authority to request autopsy reports. An autopsy report and any working papers and notes relating to an autopsy report are confidential and may be disclosed only as permitted. 45-16-27(d) 556, 385 S.E.2d 406. 5-14-3) (I.C. 90-26 (July 19, 1990) (holding that death does not extinguish confidentiality and limited disclosure pursuant to Haw. When report is return[ed] to circuit court it would be covered by Unified Judicial System rules and not open records law. . Wis. Stat. The Fatality and Mortality Review Team oversees and coordinates the examination, review and assessment of deaths resulting from drug overdoses or possible domestic violence, as well as the deaths of minor children and infants and mothers who die during pregnancy, at the time of birth or within one year of the birth of a child. W. Va. Code 61-12A-1. 97-294 (autopsy report that was never in possession of crime lab is subject to disclosure), 87-135 (autopsy report of coroner qualified to conduct post mortem tests is available under FOIA unless otherwise exempted). In holding the report not exempted from public disclosure, the court cited with approval Caswell v. Manhattan Fire and Marine Ins. To learn more about the difference between a hospital autopsy and a forensic autopsy, read on! Unless otherwise required in the furtherance of the agency's duties, the identity of the deceased is shielded. If law enforcement believes the release of any portion of the report may seriously impede an investigation, a court may order that the portion remain confidential. Veale v. City of Boca Raton, 353 So.2d 1194 (4 D.C.A. Presumably open, however, medical examiners will not release these records if they are a part of an active law enforcement investigation. During hospital autopsies, the pathologist use surgical techniques to perform an external and internal examination on the deceased. Reproductions of such materials shall be public records and shall be open to public inspection at all reasonable times."). Whether records pertaining to autopsies performed by other licensed physicians or surgeons with consent, Mo.Rev.Stat. an autopsy report shall be the same as that charged by the registrar of vital records for the state for a death certificate." Chapter 59-1242, Laws of Florida, relating to the medical examiner of Duval County makes ". See Utah Code 26-4-17. See People v. Williams, 174 Cal. Autopsy performed by order of department of labor in workers compensation occupational disease death claim case is public record. App. As such, photographs or video or audio recordings of an autopsy are highly sensitive depictions or descriptions of the deceased which, if heard, viewed, copied or publicized, could result in trauma, sorrow, humiliation, or emotional injury to the immediate family of the deceased, as well as injury to the memory of the deceased. . Law 677[3]). 271-2001, 1, 3, 4 (enumerating permitted and prohibited disclosures of autopsy records under Ind. Physician or coroner fetal death report filed with department of health. Dr. Chris M. Matsko is a retired physician based in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. 5, 458 P.3d 1048, 1057, 1059 (2020); see also Las Vegas Review-Journal v. Eighth Judicial Dist. See also Scott v. Chief Medical Examiner, 179 A.D.2d 443, 577 N.Y.S.2d 861 (1st Dept 1992), cert. (Emphasis supplied.) Perform a free Florida public record search, including arrest, birth, business, contractor, court, criminal, death, divorce, employee, genealogy, GIS, inmate, jail, land, marriage, police, property, sex offender, tax, vital, and warrant records searches. . Stat. Please visit our public records webpage for more information. . ; old (2) . To make housekeeping revisions and update the information required in autopsy reports and to update the Medical Examiners Practice Guidelines. 1083, 2001 Fla. Laws Ch. Colo. Rev. Additionally, state or federal agencies are authorized to view or copy this information. Medical Examiner case files are public record, 119.011(1)F.S. Forensic autopsies are also performed to determine the identity of the deceased, as well as the time of death and/or the fatal injury. Autopsy reports are confidential under RCW 68.50.105. However, medical information remains exempt, except as quoted in the final report. Mo.Rev.Stat. See Jeffery v. McHugh, 166 W. Va. 379, 273 S.E.2d 837 (1980) (upholding the confidentiality of juvenile court records, specifically exempt from disclosure under W. Va. Code 49-7-1, even though the juvenile involved had died). Some states (such as Louisiana and Texas) generally make autopsy reports public but certain related materials are confidential, such as photographs and videos made during the autopsy. Documents or records made confidential by statute do not lose such status upon receipt by the medical examiner. SeeShuttleworth v. City of Camden, 258 N.J. Super. Family, legal representatives, and insurers may access autopsy reports in states where the information is not public. Stat. Freedom Newspapers Inc. v. Bowerman, 739 P.2d 881 (Colo. App. v. Evansville P.C., 332 N.E.2d 829 (Ind. 2. Some records even provides birthplace of the deceased's parents. Can autopsy photographs be released where there is no known next of kin of the deceased person? Unlock expert answers by supporting wikiHow, http://pathlabs.ufl.edu/specialties/multispecialty-pathology/autopsy/, http://www.cga.ct.gov/2013/rpt/2013-R-0364.htm, https://ifs.harriscountytx.gov/Pages/AutopsyReports.aspx, obtener el informe de resultados de una autopsia, Mendapatkan Hasil dan Laporan Autopsi di Amerika Serikat. Atty Gen., No. For copies of death certificates, speak with your funeral director or contact. Before the autopsy report may be complex that the record. Iowa Code 691.6 requires the state medical examiner to keep complete records, but is silent as to the confidentiality of those records. He holds a BS in Nutritional Science from Cornell University and an MD from the Temple University School of Medicine in 2007. The full name (s) and personal information of . Do the terms "autopsy photographs or video or audio recordings," as used in Chapter 2001-01, Laws of Florida, include and thereby exempt crime scene photographs, pre-autopsy photographs of the body, and post-autopsy photographs of the body that are in the custody of the medical examiner? The statute does not address whether the coroner's inquest is confidential or public, so presumably it is public pursuant to AS 40.25.110 -.125. "Very informative. Question Three Containing over 100 million death records, the National Death Index (NDI) can help you find out who in your study has died by linking your own research datasets to death certificate information for your study subjects. Rev. Baltimore, MD 21215 410-764-3038. the records, files and information kept, retained or obtained by the County Medical Examiner [of Broward County] under the provisions of this Act shall be confidential and privileged, unless released under and by the direction of the Assistant State Attorney or County Solicitor." Atty Gen., 1972 WL 262460 (Oct. 20, 1972) (noting a medical examiners report required by 331.802 is not a confidential public record and may be examined by any citizen of Iowa); Op. 32.1-285 requires filing of all autopsy reports with the Chief Medical Examiner, with copies to the judge or Commonwealth's Attorney requesting the report. 119, F. S., to inspect and examine a particular file maintained by the Dade County Medical Examiner which contained specific and detailed information concerning a highly publicized murder. Op. Gen. Op. Herald Co. v. Murray, 136 A.D.2d 954, 524 N.Y.S.2d 949 (4th Dept 1988) (denying access to autopsy report based upon County Law 677 applicable to both autopsy reports and coroners records); New York Pub. This section provides that autopsy reports maintained by the medical examiner which resulted from suspected instances of child abuse or maltreatment, shall not be subject to the confidentiality requirements imposed under the Child Abuse Act, Ch. Are Autopsy Reports Public Record In Florida. 1996) (requiring issuance of death certificate or transcript only in certain enumerated situations and only when required for a proper purpose). Id. Florida Department of State and Division of Library and Information Services. All requests for reports are entered into the file and are reviewed once the file contents are complete. This conclusion is also supported by the recent decision in State ex rel. State may withhold if there is a pending investigation. Not public record if there is a pending criminal investigation. Coroners Reports. However, the fact that autopsy reports would not directly affect the privacy rights of any living person undoubtedly would be important in the Cline balancing process. Upon receipt of a written request from the agency, the medical examiner may show autopsy photographs as part of professional training for public agencies, provided that such training furthers the official duties of the agency. In concluding that autopsy reports must be made available for public inspection subject to the limitations contained herein, I have not overlooked the recent decision in City of Tampa v. Harold, 352 So.2d 944 (2 D.C.A. Some counties have taken the position that such reports are not public under the medical records exception and investigation exception. . Ct. April 2, 2001). QUESTIONS: (Emphasis supplied.) As contemplated by s. 406.11, F. S., it is the responsibility of the medical examiner to determine cause of death and to make and have performed such examinations, investigations, and autopsies as he shall deem necessary or shall be requested by the state attorney when, inter alia, any person dies in a manner prescribed by s. 406.11(1)(a)1.-12. Use it to try out great new products and services nationwide without paying full pricewine, food delivery, clothing and more. 2004). The Office of the Chief Medical Examiner will have most of the information that you need to request an autopsy report. Ind. Step 3: Search. Of course, the family may choose to share the information with anyone they wish, but they must give written permission for the hospital to release autopsy records, just as with any medical records. Autopsy and coroner's reports are generally available under the Open Records Act. Huston v. Turkel, 236 A.D.2d 283, 653 N.Y.S.2d 584 (1st Dept 1997) (autopsy reports are exempt from disclosure pursuant to New York City Charter 557(g)), appeal denied, 90 N.Y.2d 809, 686 N.E.2d 1365 (1997); Spencer v. New York State Police, 187 A.D.2d 919, 591 N.Y.S.2d 207 (3d Dept. See id. Under such circumstances it would appear that the medical examiner could be justified in withholding those portions of the report which, if publicized, would significantly impair the ability of law enforcement officers to apprehend those suspected of committing the crime. West Virginia Code 61-12-10 requires that "[a] full record and report of the findings developed by the autopsy shall be filed with the office of medical examinations," and requires that office to keep "full, complete, and properly indexed records of all deaths investigated, containing all relevant information concerning the death, and the autopsy report if such be made. Co., 399 F.2d 417 (5th Cir. The custodian of the record, or his or her designee, may not permit any other person to view or copy such photograph or video recording or listen to or copy an audio recording without a court order. New Jersey courts have permitted public access to autopsy reports and cause-of-death information on death certificates in limited circumstances under the common law. Photographs and recordings (video and audio) created in connection with such autopsies are subject to review and inspection, but copies may be obtained only by district attorneys, law enforcement officials and superior court judges. Does the law allow for an exemption for civil proceedings as well as criminal and administrative proceedings? [2] Section 406.11(2)(a), Fla. Public record. According to NMSA 1978 24-14-28(A), the state registrar shall provide copies to anyone "with a direct and tangible interest." 67-1704, Laws of Florida, (confidentiality of records of Martin County medical examiner and his assistants); s. 9, Ch. 1985); State v. Williams, 438 So.2d 1212 (La. Open to: Cause of death is public record. What public record in the! Att'y Gen. Ala. No. Would keeping the identity of the deceased confidential and exempt also require redaction of other identifying features, such as face recognition, tattoos, physical birth defects and other physical features that could lead to identification of the deceased? It is likely that courts would view autopsy and related records as subject to FOIA disclosure but would analyze each FOIA request to determine the extent to which disclosure might be limited by West Virginia Code 29B-1-4(2) (Information of a personal nature such as that kept in a personal, medical or similar file, if the public disclosure thereof would constitute an unreasonable invasion of privacy . The only exemption which could arguably serve to exempt autopsy reports as a category of records from s. 119.07(1), F. S., is the principle commonly known as the "police secrets rule."

What Happened To Janet Podleski, How To Cut Elfa Hanging Standards, Exorcism Of Emily Rose Actress Died, Which Washington Lottery Has Best Odds?, Articles A